Great Houses

Gregory Treat argues that modern institutions (pensions, public schools, student loans) are failed substitutes for functions the household historically performed, and that society has run out of the trust needed to sustain them. Drawing on the ordo amoris(rightly ordered loves), the biblical concept of the "guarantor," and Ricardo's comparative advantage, he argues that mutually beneficial relationships require a shared ultimate authority — and that neoliberal economics abstracts away from the individual to the nation-state precisely because we've lost the will to sort people into roles despite being very good at it. He calls for rebuilding households, churches, and patron-client relationships as intermediary structures that can restore genuine, hierarchy-based trust — including offering people risk mitigation (education, pensions, guarantees) in exchange for loyalty and specialization.